Italy fines Meta €805m over Facebook photo access
Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta €805m for accessing Android users' photos without specific consent. The regulator found the Facebook app accessed gallery data via a vague permission prompt, affecting 20 million users. Meta must disable the feature by default within 60 days. The penalty highlights strict enforcement of ePrivacy rules outside the GDPR one-stop-shop framework.
Key points
- Italy’s Garante fined Meta €805m (£670m) for violating privacy rules regarding Android user data.
- The Facebook app accessed photos and videos from 20 million users' galleries without clear, specific consent.
- Regulators ruled the case falls under ePrivacy laws, allowing Italy to act independently of Irish GDPR oversight.
- Meta has 60 days to disable the gallery suggestion feature by default and obtain separate user permission.
- The fine cites Meta's lack of cooperation and the high number of affected individuals as aggravating factors.
Regulatory Action in Italy
Italy’s data protection authority, known as the Garante, has imposed a fine of €805m on Meta, the parent company of Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp. This penalty addresses the social media giant's handling of user data on Android devices. The regulator determined that the Facebook application accessed photos, videos, and associated metadata from users' phone galleries without obtaining specific, informed consent. The decision marks one of the largest fines ever levied by an Italian authority against a technology company.
The Specific Violation
The investigation focused on a feature introduced in 2023 that suggests photos and videos from a user's local gallery as ideas for social media posts. According to the Garante, the Facebook app requested access to the entire gallery through a single, app-wide authorization prompt. This request was accompanied by a vague notice designed to enable other features, which failed to clearly inform users that granting permission would also activate the gallery suggestion function. Consequently, approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were affected by this data collection practice.
Legal Jurisdiction and ePrivacy Rules
A significant aspect of this ruling involves the legal jurisdiction under which Meta is being penalized. Meta’s European headquarters are located in Ireland, and under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the Irish Data Protection Commission typically leads investigations through a one-stop-shop mechanism. Meta argued that this case should fall under Irish jurisdiction. However, the Garante disagreed, asserting that the violation pertains to ePrivacy rules rather than GDPR. These rules do not offer a one-stop-shop provision, allowing national authorities to act independently. The regulator cited Article 122 of Italy’s privacy code, which treats a smartphone as part of a person’s private sphere, requiring free and informed consent for any access to stored data, regardless of whether the data leaves the device.
Meta’s Response and Cooperation
The Garante noted Meta’s lack of cooperation during the investigation as an aggravating factor. The regulator also considered a previous 2019 decision against Meta when calculating the fine. While changes Meta made after the initial complaint were noted, the authority emphasized the ongoing nature of the violation for users who have not updated the app or who have already consented under the flawed system. The fine reflects the high number of people affected and the seriousness of the breach.
Global Implications and Next Steps
Meta has been ordered to disable the gallery suggestion feature by default within 60 days. The company must also seek separate, explicit consent from users to enable the feature. This ruling underscores the growing scrutiny of tech giants by European regulators, particularly concerning privacy and data access. It serves as a warning that national authorities can enforce strict privacy standards even when the primary regulator is elsewhere. The fine adds to Meta’s recent legal challenges, including a $25bn penalty ordered by a US judge for misrepresenting data handling practices.
Key takeaways
- Italy fined Meta €805m for accessing Android users' photos without specific consent.
- The Facebook app used a vague permission prompt affecting 20 million users.
- The case is governed by ePrivacy rules, allowing Italian jurisdiction over Irish-based Meta.
- Meta must disable the feature by default and obtain separate consent within 60 days.
- The fine highlights strict enforcement of privacy laws and Meta's poor cooperation.
Sources
The WireByte editorial team synthesises technology news from multiple primary sources, verifies the facts, and links every source. Articles are produced with AI assistance and reviewed under our editorial policy.